
Stonewall Resort
Best for active lake-side vacations, on-site recreation, golf and families who want a resort with restaurants and a spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Stonewall Resort is a full-service lakeside resort with on-site dining, a marina, golf and a spa; this guide is for travelers who want outdoor recreation, meetings or a family getaway. SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buckhannon is a budget-focused, branded motel-style option in downtown Buckhannon for road-trippers, business travelers, and anyone prioritizing value and basic comforts.
Updated

Best for active lake-side vacations, on-site recreation, golf and families who want a resort with restaurants and a spa.

Best for straightforward, affordable nights in Buckhannon with easy access to downtown amenities, a continental breakfast, and accessible room options.
When Stonewall Resort wins: pick Stonewall if you want a resort experience — marina and lake access, an Arnold Palmer golf course, multiple restaurants and a full spa — or if you’re planning a family weekend or an event that needs meeting or wedding space.
When SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buckhannon wins: choose SureStay if you need a no-frills, value-oriented stay in downtown Buckhannon with free continental breakfast, accessible rooms, and simple business amenities like a 24-hour business center and meeting room.
Bottom line: Stonewall is the choice for activity-rich, on-property time and larger groups; SureStay is the practical pick for budget stays in town or for travelers passing through Buckhannon.
| Category | Stonewall Resort | SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buckhannon |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Full-service lakeside resort with multiple on-site activities and event space | Budget-branded, downtown hotel focused on basics and accessibility |
| Location | On Stonewall Jackson Lake inside Stonewall Resort State Park | In Buckhannon, within a short drive of Buckhannon City Hall and local shops |
| Size (rooms) | About 196 guestrooms in the lodge plus cottages and lake houses | 63 air-conditioned rooms (listing) |
| Ages | All ages; family-friendly with kids program and playground | |
| Pools / swimming | Heated indoor/outdoor pool with whirlpools (open 6am–11pm) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site restaurants and a poolside bar: Stillwaters, Lightburn's, TJ Muskies, Splash | No full-service restaurant listed on property; coffee/tea in common areas and vending |
| Spa & wellness | Mountain Laurel Spa with massages, facials and nail services (hours Tue–Sat, Sun shorter) | Not published |
| Known for | Marina, lake activities, Arnold Palmer Signature golf course, meeting and wedding venues | Value lodging with accessible rooms, free continental breakfast and business amenities |
| Accessibility | Some accessible rooms; shuttle around resort grounds | Multiple accessible room types and wheelchair-accessible public spaces |
| Business / meeting | Extensive meeting and event space (multiple ballrooms and outdoor venues) | One meeting room and a 24-hour business center |
| Parking & transport | On-site parking, valet reported on some sources; shuttle within resort | Free self parking, RV/bus/truck parking; no accessible shuttle |
Stonewall sits on the shore of Stonewall Jackson Lake inside Stonewall Resort State Park, with trails, a marina and nearby outdoor attractions.
Pick Stonewall if you want a stay centered on lake activities and trails.
SureStay is a downtown Buckhannon property in a rural town setting, within a few minutes’ drive of city hall and local services.
Pick SureStay if you need convenient access to Buckhannon town and local services.
Stonewall offers lodge rooms, cottages and lake houses in a variety of layouts — from standard rooms to Presidential Suite and 2‑bedroom cottages.
Stonewall is better when you want resort-style room variety and lake views.
SureStay’s inventory centers on standard queen/king and two-queen layouts, with many accessible-room configurations and some junior suites.
SureStay works well for travelers who need accessible rooms and basic in-room amenities.
Stonewall has several sit-down restaurants and bar options covering breakfast through dinner and seasonal poolside service.
Choose Stonewall for varied on-site dining and a dinner option that fits different moods.
SureStay provides a complimentary continental/continental-style breakfast and common-area coffee; no on-site full-service restaurants are listed.
SureStay is best when you only need a simple morning meal and on-the-go options in town.
Stonewall’s signature amenities are lake access and the heated indoor/outdoor pool that connects inside and outside.
The lake and pool setup is Stonewall’s core draw for activity-focused stays.
SureStay’s property focuses on practical guest services rather than resort recreation.
SureStay’s strengths are convenience and practical services for short stays.
Stonewall provides a full spa and fitness facilities plus a casual bar for evening drinks.
Stonewall fits travelers who plan to use spa and fitness services or want an on-site evening out.
SureStay offers standard hotel fitness/business basics but no published spa or nightlife venues.
SureStay is aimed at practical needs rather than wellness or nightlife.

Stonewall — marina, boat rentals and lake cruises put water activities on your doorstep.

SureStay — affordable rooms, free continental breakfast and downtown location make it a practical choice.

Stonewall — extensive indoor/outdoor event spaces and multiple ballrooms for weddings and conferences.

SureStay — many accessible room types, 24-hour business center and a meeting room for small groups.
Stonewall — it’s family-oriented with a kids program, playground, marina activities and several on-site restaurants.
SureStay includes a complimentary continental breakfast; Stonewall offers a buffet breakfast for a fee (not automatically included in the room rate).
Yes at Stonewall (Mountain Laurel Spa). SureStay has no published on-site spa.
Stonewall — it has extensive meeting/event space and multiple wedding venues; SureStay offers a single meeting room for smaller needs.
Explore how Stonewall Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·